Passive and Active RFID tags are different technologies that are often evaluated together. Both RFID tags use Radio Frequency (RF) energy to communicate between the tag and readers.
Active RFID tags use an internal power source (battery) to continuously power the tag. Their lifespan is determined by the power of the battery, once the battery fails, so does the tag. They have very low signal strengths to communicate with the readers. Since they are continuously powered, they can be read within a range of 100 feet. Active tags have a high data transmission rate, allowing thousands of tags to be read in at once within their read-range. They also have low orientation sensitivity, allowing the reader to pick up multiple orientations during its read-time. Active RFID tags are cost-heavy, often starting at $10/tag. Typically active RFID tags can be found in place like consumer goods, vehicles, postal items, and retail pallets.
Passive RFID tags do not contain an internal power source, but rather are powered by a reader. This gives passive tags an unlimited lifespan. They require high signal strength from the reader to respond. Their read range is low, up to 20 feet. A few hundred can be read within their range. These tags have high orientation sensitivity, meaning it’s more difficult to read them in certain positions. Passive RFID tags are cost-effect, typically ranging from $0.15-$5.00/tag. You would find passive tags in places such as healthcare, books, animal chips, and travel documents (passports). See how RFID tags can improve your data center audits.
Here’s a table showing a full comparison:
Passive RFID Tags |
Active RFID Tags
|
|
Power Source | No internal power source; powered by the RFID reader’s signal. |
Contains an internal power source (typically a battery) for signal transmission.
|
Read Range | Shorter read range, typically up to 25 feet (7.6 meters). |
Longer read range, often exceeding 100 feet (30 meters).
|
Cost | Generally more cost-effective than active tags. |
More expensive due to the added battery and longer-range capabilities.
|
Maintenance | Maintenance-free; no battery replacement needed. |
Batteries require periodic replacement, increasing ongoing costs.
|
Read Accuracy | Typically less accurate due to shorter read range. |
More accurate and reliable due to extended read range and constant power supply.
|
Application Scenarios | Ideal for asset tracking within a confined space or proximity (e.g., inventory management). |
Suited for tracking assets across large areas, outdoor applications, and real-time monitoring.
|
Battery Life | N/A |
Battery life varies but usually ranges from a few months to several years.
|
Real-Time Tracking | Not designed for real-time tracking; batch processing is common. |
Supports real-time tracking, providing constant updates on asset location.
|
Size | Smaller and lighter, suitable for compact assets. |
Larger and heavier due to the built-in battery; may be cumbersome for small items.
|
Environmental Considerations | Limited ability to withstand extreme conditions. |
More rugged and able to handle harsh environments.
|
Implementation Complexity | Simpler deployment; often plug-and-play. |
Requires more complex setup due to battery management and network integration.
|
Use Cases | Retail inventory, supply chain, access control, and short-range asset tracking. |
Logistics, vehicle tracking, wildlife monitoring, and long-range asset tracking.
|
Cost of Ownership | Lower initial costs but may result in higher operational costs for frequent maintenance. |
Higher initial investment, but lower operational costs due to extended battery life.
|
Few other things to consider are hardware, visibility and range, scanning processes, software requirements, durability (passive are more durable).
In specialized fields like chemical inventory, the choice between passive and active RFID tags is crucial. Learn how they integrate with chemical inventory management software.
Applications and Use Cases for Passive and Active RFID Tags
Passive RFID tags are ideal for retail environments, where their low cost and short read range suit inventory tracking. They’re used for tracking consumer goods, library books, and clothing items. In contrast, active RFID tags, with their longer read range and larger size, are suited for tracking high-value assets over larger areas. They’re commonly used in healthcare for monitoring patient movements and managing medical equipment, and in logistics for tracking goods in large warehouses or across supply chains.
Future Trends and Innovations in RFID Technology
The future of RFID technology is heading towards greater integration with the Internet of Things (IoT), enhancing the capabilities of both passive and active tags. Innovations in battery technology are expected to extend the lifespan of active RFID tags, making them more viable for long-term tracking solutions. Enhanced data storage and security features in passive tags will improve their applicability in sectors requiring detailed asset information. Upcoming trends include the development of smaller, more efficient tags and the use of RFID in combination with other technologies like AI and blockchain for improved asset management and security.
Passive RFID vs Active RFID: Verdict
Passive RFID tags are powered by an RFID reader or antenna and have a lower signal range than active RFID tags. They are commonly used for tracking inventory, supply chain management, and access control. They are also a cheaper option, with an average price of just $0.08 per tag. Passive RFID tags are ideal for things that are stored for extended periods of time or only need to be tracked for a short period.
Active RFID tags, on the other hand, have a built-in power source and can automatically broadcast their location to a reader. They are commonly used in processes to track assets in real-time, such as vehicle tracking and tolling. Active RFID tags have a larger read range, with a signal range of up to 150 meters, and are the best choice for real-time tracking. However, they are more expensive than passive RFID tags.
In summary, the choice between passive and active RFID tags depends on the specific tracking needs and budget. For short-term tracking of inventory or access control, passive RFID tags are a cost-effective option. For real-time tracking of high-value assets, active RFID tags are the better choice.
Need Help?
FAQ
A passive RFID tag is a type of radio frequency identification tag that is smaller and less expensive than its active counterpart. It consists of a tag, tag antenna, and reader. Unlike active tags, passive tags don’t send their own signal. Instead, they are scanned by a signal sent from a handheld reader. The reader sends energy to the tag’s antenna, which turns the energy into radio frequency waves and sends a signal, called “backscatter,” back to the reader. Passive RFID tags have no power of their own and are powered by the radio frequency energy transmitted from RFID readers/antennas.
An RFID reader and an RFID antenna are both components of an RFID system, but they serve different functions. Here are the key differences between the two:
RFID Antenna:
- An RFID antenna is responsible for emitting radio waves that are used to retrieve signals from RFID tags.
- Antennas can be either internal or external to the reader.
- Antennas can be mobile or mounted in a fixed location, such as on a tall pole in a warehouse.
- Antennas can connect wirelessly to the reader in more complex systems.
Example: The tag antenna in a passive RFID tracking system turns energy from a handheld reader into radio frequency waves and sends a signal back to the reader.
RFID Reader: - An RFID reader evaluates information in real-time and can transmit the data to a software system where it is stored and referenced as needed.
- Readers can be either fixed or handheld.
- Handheld readers are mobile and can be taken anywhere, while fixed readers are mounted in one location.
- Readers can be used to trigger signals from active RFID tags.
Example: The reader in an active RFID tracking system receives signals from the antenna of a battery-powered tag and can locate the tag if it is within the read range.
In summary, the RFID antenna emits radio waves and retrieves signals from RFID tags, while the RFID reader evaluates the information and transmits it to a software system. The antenna is responsible for communicating with the tag, while the reader is responsible for communicating with the software system.
An RFID tracking system can collect various types of data from fixed or movable assets using radio frequency identification tags and electromagnetic readers. The data collected includes the location, condition, and maintenance needs of the assets. Additionally, RFID can aid in environmental monitoring, such as identifying contamination in controlled pharmaceutical environments. The collected data can be stored on a computer system and used to optimize asset usage, manage inventory, monitor stock levels, and track the movement of goods. RFID systems can enhance health and safety requirements, improve accountability, and reduce staff time and human intervention.
Real-time tracking in RFID asset tracking and inventory management offers several benefits, including increased accuracy, improved efficiency, and reduced labor costs. With RFID technology, assets can be located with far more precision than other methods, such as bar codes and GPS. Real-time tracking allows for instant scanning and identification of all tagged objects and people, reducing the time spent searching for items and increasing workplace efficiency. Additionally, RFID data is accurate and trusted, reducing the risk of errors and improving inventory accuracy. Overall, real-time tracking with RFID technology streamlines operations, reduces costs, and increases asset visibility.